Blog Topics

Join Our List

Want to get content ideas and marketing strategies for your construction business? Join our list and receive informational blog posts and insights straight to your inbox.

No spam, no sales pitches, no BS. Just good content ideas and tips.

Vinyl Vs. Polymer

Comparing Siding

January 22, 2024
steps in home building process

In the ever-evolving world of home improvement, choosing the right siding material for your home can make all the difference between sighs of satisfaction and groans of regret. Enter two heavyweight contenders of siding: vinyl and polymer. As you prepare to pick a side in this battle, we offer you a comprehensive comparison between vinyl siding and polymer siding. Strap in as we dismantle the hype, examine the realities, scratch beneath the surface beauty, and show you exactly what makes each contender tick – with both their winning punches and weak jabs covered alike. Dive into the ultimate face-off to determine which one will champion your home improvement project!

Understanding Vinyl Siding

Vinyl siding has been a popular choice for home exterior renovations for decades. It is widely produced, versatile, and affordable, making it accessible to a wide range of homeowners. Vinyl siding is made of polyvinyl chloride (PVC), a type of plastic that is rigid yet flexible. This unique composition gives vinyl siding its strength and durability while allowing for some flexibility during installation to accommodate the natural movement of the house.

Vinyl siding offers several advantages that account for its popularity among homeowners. One of the major benefits is cost-effectiveness. Vinyl siding is relatively inexpensive compared to other materials like stone or fiber cement, making it an affordable option for those on a tighter budget. This affordability extends to the installation process as well, reducing overall project costs.

With vinyl siding, homeowners have endless options in terms of colors and styles. Whether you prefer the classic look of horizontal or vertical panels, or you want to mimic the appearance of cedar shake or stone, vinyl siding offers a wide range of aesthetic choices. With advancements in technology, manufacturers have even introduced textured finishes that closely resemble wood grain, adding dimension and authenticity to your home's exterior.

Vinyl siding is also known for its low-maintenance properties. Unlike wood or other traditional materials, vinyl does not require painting or staining. A simple yearly cleaning with soap and water can keep your siding looking fresh and vibrant. Additionally, vinyl is decay-proof and resistant to pests such as termites, offering long-term protection for your home.

Despite all of vinyl siding’s benefits, it's important to note that it does have its limitations. Extreme temperatures can cause vinyl to expand or contract, potentially leading to warping or buckling if not installed correctly, with proper allowances for thermal movement. Additionally, exposure to intense heat sources like grills or fire pits can melt or distort vinyl siding panels. While rare, severe hailstorms could also result in dents or cracks on the surface of the vinyl.

Additionally, while advancements have been made in terms of color retention, some lower-quality vinyl sidings may fade or discolor over time due to prolonged exposure to UV rays. It's crucial to choose reputable manufacturers and check for warranties when investing in vinyl siding.

Some critics argue that vinyl siding can detract from a home's value or architectural integrity, especially when used in historic neighborhoods or high-end communities. While this viewpoint holds some validity, it ultimately depends on individual preferences and the overall style of your neighborhood. High-quality vinyl products can be just as durable and visually appealing as other, more expensive options.

Unveiling Polymer Siding

Polymer siding, a popular alternative to traditional materials, offers homeowners a durable and versatile option for enhancing the exterior of their homes. Made from polypropylene resin, polymer siding provides several advantages over other siding materials. One key feature of polymer siding is its ability to mimic the appearance of various materials like wood or stucco, giving homeowners the flexibility to achieve their desired aesthetic while benefiting from the durability and low-maintenance properties of plastic.

Polymer siding is known for its exceptional resilience and resistance to impact, warping, and heat. Unlike wood siding, it does not rot or deteriorate over time due to moisture or termite damage. This makes it an attractive option for homeowners looking for a long-lasting solution without the need for frequent repairs or replacements. Additionally, polymer siding is available in a wide range of colors and styles, allowing homeowners to customize their home's exterior according to personal preferences.

In terms of maintenance requirements, polymer siding is relatively low maintenance compared to other materials. It does not require periodic painting or sealing like wood siding, which can save homeowners both time and maintenance costs. With a simple routine cleaning, polymer siding can maintain its appearance and structural integrity for years.

Another advantage of polymer siding is its environmental friendliness during the production process compared to vinyl siding. The production of polymer siding requires less energy and fewer harmful chemicals, making it a greener choice overall. However, it is important to note that polymer siding tends to be costlier than vinyl siding due to its enhanced features and manufacturing process.

However, it's important to weigh the advantages against the potential drawbacks. One notable drawback of polymer siding is its higher initial cost compared to traditional options like vinyl siding. While it offers enhanced features and durability, this can come at a higher price point. Homeowners will need to consider their budget and long-term goals when deciding whether the added benefits of polymer siding outweigh the upfront cost.

Additionally, although polymer siding has made significant strides in replicating the appearance of authentic materials like wood or stucco, it may not achieve the exact same level of authenticity as these natural products. This trade-off between aesthetics and durability is important to consider when making your siding selection.

Comparing Vinyl and Polymer

While the two types of siding may appear similar at first glance, there are distinct differences between the two that can impact your decision. Let's explore the key factors to consider when comparing vinyl and polymer siding.

Vinyl siding, as mentioned earlier, is primarily made from polyvinyl chloride (PVC) resin. It has been a go-to choice for many homeowners due to its affordability, wide availability, and low maintenance requirements. On the other hand, polymer siding is a relatively newer option in the market. It is made from a blend of polypropylene resin and other additives, which enhances its durability and performance.

To better understand the comparison, let's imagine you're searching for a siding material that combines aesthetics, durability, and cost-effectiveness for your home exterior. Analyzing these factors will help you make an informed decision regarding vinyl or polymer siding.

  • Aesthetics: Both vinyl and polymer sidings come in a variety of colors, textures, and styles to suit different architectural designs. However, many agree that polymer siding has a slight edge in terms of mimicking natural materials like wood or stone more realistically. Its blend of polypropylene resin and additives allows for greater versatility in achieving authentic looks.
  • Durability: When it comes to durability, both vinyl and polymer sidings offer excellent resistance against harsh weather conditions such as rain, wind, and UV rays. However, due to its additional additives and formulation techniques used during manufacturing, polymer siding tends to be slightly more durable than traditional vinyl siding. This enhanced durability also translates into better impact resistance against accidental damage or fading over time.
  • Cost: In terms of cost-effectiveness, vinyl siding often takes the lead. It is known for being one of the most affordable siding options available. Its lower cost is attributed to its widespread availability, simplified installation process, and ease of manufacturing. On the other hand, polymer siding usually comes at a higher price point due to its enhanced durability and more intricate manufacturing process.
  • Lifespan: While both vinyl and polymer sidings offer commendable longevity, polymer has been found to last up to six decades or more, surpassing the typical lifespan of about 40 years for vinyl siding. This increased durability can be particularly advantageous for homeowners living in areas with extreme weather conditions or regions prone to damage from heavy winds or hailstorms.
  • Maintenance: Both types of siding require regular cleaning and maintenance to prevent the growth of mold and mildew, as well as to preserve their appearance and functionality. Neglecting this aspect could result in a decrease in lifespan and visual appeal for both vinyl and polymer siding.

Now that we have compared the aesthetics, durability, lifespan, and cost factors between vinyl and polymer sidings, it's important to weigh these aspects against your specific needs and priorities before making a final decision.

Final Judgment: Vinyl or Polymer?

After exploring the pros and cons of vinyl siding and polymer siding, it's time to address the ultimate question: Which is the better choice? The decision between vinyl and polymer siding ultimately boils down to personal preferences and various factors like budget, aesthetic appeal, durability, and local climate.

For those who prioritize cost-effectiveness and a wide range of style options, vinyl siding may be the more reasonable choice. However, if one values superior resistance, durability, and environmental friendliness, polymer siding might be worth considering. 

Whether you decide on vinyl siding or polymer siding, both choices have their merits. Take the time to research different brands and consult with experienced professionals who can help guide you towards the best solution based on your unique requirements.

We Know Construction

Construction Marketing is a full-service marketing and advertising agency that works exclusively with clients in the construction industry. We provide a wide range of effective marketing strategies to help your brand stand out in this oversaturated market. Our team will create an entire marketing plan that is unique to your brand and is directly targeted to your desired customer base. We help your firm achieve its goals and reach the next level of growth. Call us to schedule a meeting to discuss your business goals and we’ll take it from there.

Contact Us Today
Web marketing and design services for the construction industry